Saints Nation: Has Sedrick Ellis Lived Up to Expectations?

A guy that’s been mostly under the radar in his 4 years as a member of the Saints, mostly due to all the other big names on the roster, is former 1st round pick Sedrick Ellis. When the Saints took Ellis 7th overall in the 2008 draft, trading up from the 10th slot and giving up a 3rd round pick to the Patriots to get him, expectations were extremely high. Ellis, at the time, was one of three USC players in team history to bench over 500 lbs. He came into the NFL as the kind of player that was respected as very versatile for an interior lineman, very capable regardless of the down and distance. He had the luxury of being big, strong, but also explosive for his size. But has he lived up to his pre-draft hype?

Ellis came out of the gates with an extremely strong rookie campaign that created even more promise, before having a slight dip in performance in 2009. 2009 was still a pretty good year, though, and obviously the team had tremendous success that season. 2010 was his breakout year, as Ellis notched career highs in tackles (44), sacks (6) and games played in a season (16). Entering the prime of his career, it was fair to think Ellis would perform even better alongside Aubrayo Franklin and Shaun Rodgers in 2011. But Ellis fell flat last year and had his worst statistical season of his career, notching career lows for a season in tackles (29) and sacks (0.5). Granted, he was rotated more than any other years thanks to the newfound depth at the position, and the poor performance on defense seemed to be a widespread problem across the unit in 2011, but it was a discouraging step back for a player that seemed to be coming into his own as an NFL star.

That’s kind of been Ellis’ career so far with the Saints, in a nutshell. In 4 years, he’s had two solid seasons followed up by regressions. Impressive and teetering the edge of stardom at times, and surprisingly passive and disappointing at others. Here’s how Pro Football Focus rated each of his 4 seasons, which actually views Ellis as pretty middle of the road:

2008: +8.6 rating total, 16th best among interior linemen. +17.2 rating in pass rushing (3rd best in NFL) but a -10.7 rating in run defense (8th worst). That was based on 86 graded players.

2009: -3.0 rating total, 47th best among interior linemen. -1.5 rating in pass rushing (37th) and -3.1 rating in run defense (57th). That was based on 87 graded players.

2010: -4.8 rating total, 58th best among interior linemen. -3.3 rating in pass rushing (51st) and -4.0 rating in run defense (62nd). That was based on 77 graded players.

2011: +0.6 rating total, 51st best among interior linemen. -1.4 rating in pass rushing (37th) and -2.3 rating in run defense (74th). That was based on 88 graded players.

So it’s interesting. If you look at PFF’s grades, they seem to think his rookie season was by far his best, even though 2010 was better statistically. Not surprisingly, Ellis has graded out each year much better in pass rushing situations than run defense. He’s come out each year grading very poorly in run defense, and the best he’s ever finished was rated 57th out of 87 graded players in that department. It’s slightly shocking to see PFF think of him as a middle of the road, at best, defensive tackle. Based on these grades, I don’t see how you can argue Ellis was worth the 7th overall pick. Granted, PFF isn’t the end all be all, and I don’t necessarily take their ratings as gospel, but I have to say their scores end up being pretty close to the scores I give in my grading. Obviously the point system is different from my GPA system, but the ranking of each Saints’ player in order of best to worst usually comes out very close… so at the very least I respect their system as pretty accurate. That said, there’s probably more room for error and differential if it’s not the same person grading each player each week.

Sedrick Ellis is entering the final year of his rookie contract, which will pay him $5.816 million this season. After that, he’s an unrestricted free agent and the Saints will have to decide whether they bring him back or let him walk. Ellis will of course have to decide if he wants to return, as well. Given what decent DT’s cost, given the Saints’ cap woes, and given the fact that they just invested in Brodrick Bunkley for 5 years at the same position, Ellis may not be retained. Quite simply, he just hasn’t been able to become the dominant and reliable player the Saints hoped he would be. Still, you have to like the fact that in a contract year we’ll probably see the most determined and effort filled season yet from Ellis. If he wants to get a big second contract and earn leaguewide respect as one of the best, now would be the time to step up.

Andrew Juge

About Andrew Juge

I like the Saints. A lot.

Quantcast